Moshe Shemesh
Ahmad al-Shuqayri / Shukeiri / Shukairy (ash-Shuqayri) is best known for his statement ahead of the 1967 six day war to "throw the Jews into the sea." 1 2
Mr Shukairy claims that when in his days of glory he publicly advocated the liquidation of Israel and “sweeping of the Jews into the sea”, he reflected the accepted official Arab outlook, an outlook that was changed only by the outcome of the war of 1967.Mr Shukairy is indignant that such extremism should be fathered on him alone ...
Shukairy sank into obscurity, and later (in May 1971) published his apologia, which he called Dialogues and Secrets with Kings (in Beirut in Arabic).In it he defended his notorious demand 'to liquidate the state of Israel and throw the Jews into the sea' as being the accepted view then of the Arab heads of state, Arab politicians, who had since turned on him and prised him from office and the Arab press...
Shukeiri made sure it's understood as is, literal. As these progressives have put it in 1976:
'In Search of Facts, Ideas and Challenges,' Vol. 5, Iss. 80. Vol. 8, Iss. 159. 'Institute for the Study of Relevant Progressivism.' 1976.
The P.L.O. - What Sort of Precedent?https://books.google.com/books?id=k5eyAAAAIAAJ&q=%22shukairy%22
This Once Even the Right Could be Righ
...professing its genocidal ambition openly, without hiding it in any disguise whatever. Its leader, Ahmed Shukairy, kept making a point of it that the Arabs were absolutely literal when speaking of pushing the Israelis into the sea. Following the military disaster Israel that year inflicted on the Arabs, they were internationally overheard discussing the public relations error of their past genocidal candor. Heads of Arab states and Palestinian leaders were voicing this tactical self-criticism in newspaper interviews and articles, in radio and television broadcasts, in speeches before parliaments.
The adjustments made in the aftermath of this self-criticism included the replacement of the undiplomatic Ahmed Shukairy with the highly diplomatic Yassir Arafat as leader of the Palestine Liberation Organization. Also included was a new semantic formula which, incorporated in the Charter of the PLO, for the first time provided however thin and tortuous a camouflage of the genocidal ambition. What used up until that point to be loudly and proudly advertised was now being pro forma denied whenever necessary, accompanied by a meaningful wink of an eyelid.
The greatest immediate danger to peace in the Near East today is the Arab refusal to become reconciled to the existence of Israel on the shores of the Holy Land. Grave fears prevail among American and other Western diplomats in the area that the recent assassination of King Abdullah of Jordan may lead to a resumption of Arab hostilities against the Jewish state. The ill-fated King, who was shot through the heart in Jerusalem by an Arab terrorist... This burning issue is fanning the flames of religious fanaticism and fostering fierce nationalism.
Denied by the Western powers the arms they would like to secure for another effort to drive the Jews into the sea....
Nearly 2,000 Persons Killed in Two Years of War Waged by Arabs To Drive Jews Into Sea Palestine Has Become Home of Murder, Arson and Pillage on Wholesale Scale, Knickerbocker Declares (Editor's Note: Nearly 2,000 persons have been killed in the two years of war waged by Arabs to drive the Jews into the sea and the British out of Palestine. H. R. Knickerbocker, the noted foreign correspondent of International News Service, reveals in the following article, third of a series of 12 on "War in the Holy Land." In this installment, the Pulitzer prize winning journalist tells how Palestine has become the home ol mm der, arson and pillage on a wholesale scale not equalled elsewhere in the world except in the war...
Saudi Arabia Attacks West, Supports Syria UNITED NATIONS, Oct. 2 (AP) -Saudi Arabia today blamed Western nations for Middle East tension and called for a U.N. "hands off" policy toward Syria.Ahmad Shukairy... Saudi Arabia, told the 82-nation General Assembly "it is the policy of the West that is destroying ties with the Arabs." He proclaimed Saudi Arabia's full solidarity with Syria and asserted shipments of Communist arms to that country are no business of the United Nations. He called for the United Nations to establish an agency to "facilitate the repatriation of Israelis to their former homes." He said "we do not intend to throw the Jews to the sea," but wish them "a better and happier life in their homelands, where they can settle, under U.N. auspices." Deplored by British Shukairy is a Palestinian Arab who represented Syria at past U.N. sessions. He is head of the U.N. delegation for Saudi Arabia, whose King Saud is re carded bv the United States as a friend in the Middle fast..
"Jews who were living permanently in Palestine until the beginning of the Zionist invasion will be considered Palestinians,” Article 6 reads, but it does not define when the “Zionist invasion” began.Other documents issued by the PLO and al - Fatah have dated it variously as from the creation of the State of Israel in 1948 or from the publication of the Balfour Declaration in 1917. In his speech before the United Nations on November 13, 1974, Arafat extended the date even further in the past declaring, “The Jewish invasion of Palestine began in 1881."By almost any three definitions, most Jews presently living in Israel would be considered illegal immigrants in a PLO - dominated Palestine and either driven out or exterminated.Shukeiri in his heyday as head of the PLO often spoke of "driving the Jews into the sea.” Later, for the same reason the article was originally kept secret, he explained that what he meant by this was that “since Jews had come to Palestine by sea they should return to their homes the same way."The PLO has at times, especially today, attempted to project a moderate imageby talking about replacing Israel with a “democratic , secular Palestine in which Muslims, Christians, and Jews would live together equally."The fact is that there is not one example of a democratic or secular state anywhere in the Arab or Muslim world. The lack of democracy is generally known; what is not so well known is that each and every Arab state includes in its constitution an article establishing Islam as the state religion.
עיונים בתקומת ישראל, 11, 2001, עמ' 141-132. משה שמש - האם קרא שוקירי 'לזרוק את היהודים לים'?
... העובדה שבאותה הצהרה דיבר במפורש על השמדת יהודים חיזקה את אמינותה של הטענה. שהוא קרא לזרוק את היהודים לים...]
Iyunim Bitkumat Yisrael, (Merkaz le-moreshet Ben-Gurion) Vol. 11, pp. 132-141, 2001.
Moshe Shemesh - Did Shuqayri call for 'throwing the Jews into the sea'?
... The fact that in that statement he explicitly spoke of the extermination of Jews strengthened the credibility of the claim. That he called for throwing the Jews into the .. sea ...
https://in.bgu.ac.il/bgi/iyunim/11/5.pdf
[עיונים בתקומת ישראל. מאסף לבעיות הציונות, היישוב ומדינת ישראל].
2001. Volume 11. p.134
https://books.google.com/books?id=7ZxtAAAAMAAJ&q=%22%D7%94%D7%A2%D7%95%D7%91%D7%93%D7%94+%D7%A9%D7%91%D7%90%D7%95%D7%AA%D7%94+%D7%94%D7%A6%D7%94%D7%A8%D7%94+%D7%93%D7%99%D7%91%D7%A8+%D7%91%D7%9E%D7%A4%D7%95%D7%A8%D7%A9+%D7%A2%D7%9C+%D7%94%D7%A9%D7%9E%D7%93%D7%AA+%D7%99%D7%94%D7%95%D7%93%D7%99%D7%9D+%D7%97%D7%99%D7%96%D7%A7%D7%94+%D7%90%D7%AA+%D7%90%D7%9E%D7%99%D7%A0%D7%95%D7%AA%D7%94+%D7%A9%D7%9C+%D7%94%D7%98%D7%A2%D7%A0%D7%94%22
Israel Studies: IS. Volume 8.
Indiana University Press, 2003. pp. 71-72
p.71
'But in my estimation non of them will survive.'
https://books.google.com/books?id=-0wMAQAAMAAJ&q=%22But+in+my+estimation+none+of+them+will+survive%22
https://books.google.com/books?id=-0wMAQAAMAAJ&focus=searchwithinvolume&q=%22None%22
p.72
The fact that his announcement referred explicitly to the annihilation of the Jews strengthened the credibility of the claim that he had called for throwing them into the sea.
https://books.google.com/books?id=-0wMAQAAMAAJ&q=The+fact+that+in+that+statement+he+explicitly+spoke+of+the+extermination+of+Jews+strengthened+the+credibility+of+the+claim
EVALUATION
The version in the Lebanese newspaper al-Yawm gives the impression of being closer to the truth than the doctored one in Shuqayri's memories. Although radical, the statement does not appear to imply that he intended to throw the Jews who "remained in Filastin," into the sea "if any remained." His intention was that they would be deported overseas, by ship, to their countries of origin, in other words, by the same way they came to Israel. At the same time, his statement "in my estimate none of them would remain alive" obviously sounded like the intention to destroy or liquidate the Jews and that their fate was sealed. It certainly lent credibility to the claim that he had called for throwing the Jews into the sea.
Did Shuqayri Call to Throw the Jews into the Sea?Moshe ShemeshOn the eve of the Six Days War, Ahmad al-Shuqayri, the PLO Chairman in theyears 1964-1967, made a statement in Amman that implied throwing the Jews ofIsrael into the sea following the successful occupation of Israel by the Arab armies.According to Shuqayri, Israeli propaganda defamed his alleged statement as indication or proof of the Arabs’ hostility towards Israel thus justifying her military offensive on 5 June 1967. Western and Arab researchers also used this declaration against Shuqayri himself after the war.Shuqayri categorically denied this allegation but failed to convince. He argued that ‘This was one of the biggest lies the Zionist propaganda had spread’. HelenaCobban wrote in her book The Palestinian Liberation Organization: People, Power and Politics(1984): ‘For his part, Shuqayri was remembered in later years, even by many Palestinians as the man who gave the Palestinians a bad name by threatening to throw the Jews into the sea’.The origin of this allegation was a statement Shuqayri made in Amman on 2 June 1967, and which was published by the Lebanese newspaper al-Yom, on 3 June 1967.According to the newspaper, Shuqayri was asked at a press conference ‘What would happen to the inhabitants of Israel if the Arabs won the war?’. To this Shuqayri replied: ‘We will endeavor to help them and ease their departure [from Israel] through the sea to the countries from which they came [to Israel]’. To the question what would be the destiny of the Israelis who were born in Israel, Shuqayri answered:‘All those who will remain alive [of the Israelis who were born in Israel] will stay in Filastin, but I think none of them will remain alive’.The study concludes that Shuqayri’s statement was indeed an expression of extreme enmity towards Israel, but it did not imply throwing ‘the Jews who remain in Filastin, if any will remain’, into the sea. His intention was that those who remained alive would be deported to the countries of their origin, in ships via the sea, the same way they had arrived in Israel. Nevertheless, it should be emphasized that it is clear from his statement that his aim was to annihilate the Jews when he said ‘I think none of them will remain alive’, thus there would be no question of their future survival.
Gilbert Achcar & Shukairy
1. Exposing Gilbert Achcar
Jonathan G. Campbell, Lesley D. Klaff: 'Unity and Diversity in Contemporary Antisemitism.'
The Bristol–Sheffield Hallam Colloquium on Contemporary Antisemitism. (Academic Studies Press) 2019
They are damned to play the role of the oppressed for whom intellectuals such as Gilbert Achcar tirelessly seek excuses. Maajid Nawaz calls this approach "patronizing, self-pity inspiring and mollycoddling." To infantilize the Arabs by strictly separating the West and the East when it comes to antisemitism and Holocaust denial is of course a kind of racism in
But some might call it a "racism of low expectations," as if a Muslim person is "supposed" to uphold appalling views, while others might call it "paternalistic racism."
Another reason to neglect or downplay Arab antisemitism is the widespread bias against Israel.
Achcar is a convinced anti-Zionist who has called the two-state solution, as recommended by the United Nations General Assembly in 1947 "a dishonorable surrender". He plays down the antisemitism of Hamas in order to delegitimize Israel and its defensive efforts.
However, even in circumstances where prejudice against Israel is less evidently a factor, Arab Jew- hatred is still often ignored...
https://books.google.com/books?id=E8zBDwAAQBAJ&pg=PT147
'In the Straightjacket of Anti-Zionism. A critical review of Gilbert Achcar's The Arabs and the Holocaust.' by Matthias Küntzel and Colin Meade:
This is a book in which an author from the political left seeks to protect the dogmas of Western anti-Zionism from the reality of Arab anti-Semitism.
http://engageonline.files.wordpress.com/2011/09/in-the-straightjacket-of-anti-zionism2.pdf
Jeffrey Herf Reviews "The Arabs and the Holocaust: The Arab-Israeli War of Narratives" | The New Republic. Oct. 31, 2010
Not in Moderation.
Partisanship is almost always just beneath the surface of most writing about the Middle East. Gilbert Achcar’s book is no exception.
https://newrepublic.com/article/78714/not-in-moderation
'Gilbert Achcar's Anti-Zionism of Fools.' by Cinnamon Stillwell and Rima Greene. ME Forum. November 10, 2011
— "Don't expect me to take a pro-Israel view. I'm an Arab." So declared Gilbert Achcar— professor of development studies and international relations.
https://www.meforum.org/campus-watch/19595/gilbert-achcar-anti-zionism-of-fools
Related, on Achcar biased "research" , from a historian:
Haggai Erlich: 'The Middle East Between the Two Wars,' Volume 2; Volume 5, Open University of Israel, 2002, p.81:
'Even the newspaper Filastin ("Palestine"), which criticized Mussolini, supported Hitler, as did almost all other newspapers.'
Now, this Gilbert Achcar (in his 2010 book, p.199) admits re Shuqayri:
While he did not literally call for throwing the Jews into the sea, as he was accused of doing, in substance he made much the same demand, if not, indeed, worse. His declaration reflected the position of the Higher Arab Committee, headed by Amin al-Husseini, which Shuqayri had joined at the end of the Second World War...
https://books.google.com/books?id=3q5dFD61V5oC&q=&pg=PA199

https://naamoush.wordpress.com/2019/08/27/le-grand-vainuc-%d7%94%d7%9e%d7%a0%d7%a6%d7%97-%d7%94%d7%92%d7%93%d7%95%d7%9c/
A soldier [Israeli] browses with pleasure in a Syrian newspaper. At the main page - a cartoon showing the Syrian army sending the Zionists
Comments
Post a Comment